» » »

The Entanglement Illusion

No, I am not a quantum mechanic, nor do I play one on TV.  However, I have long been concerned that the widespread success of the mathematical framework known as quantum mechanics has lumbered physics with a corollary notion known as "entanglement" that posits the idea that previously associated sub-atomic particles can stay interconnected over long physical distances.

 

As a Skeptic, I am bothered by the growing acceptance of the concept of entanglement as a fact by physicists because it is absurd on its face, and worse, has provided the general public with a justification for belief in telepathy and other similar paranormal abilities.  In the early days of quantum mechanics, Einstein expressed his conviction that quantum mechanics was not a complete characterization of reality because of its probablistic description of the sub-atomic world, saying: "I don't believe that God plays dice with the universe" and calling entanglement a "spooky action at a distance".  But in 1964, a physicist named John Bell published a paper with a formula he said could verify whether or not entanglement was really a fact.  Subsequent experiments by other physicists whose findings were interpreted according to Bell's formula, lent increasing creedence to entanglement as a fact.  So for the last 45 years, entanglement has gained virtually universal acceptance, and the popular culture has increasingly looked to entanglement to legitimize its belief in telepathy.

 

In addition, a fresh crop of entrepreneurial physicists has declared that entanglement can be used as the basis for a new type of computer, called a quantum computer.  This type of computer could be very significant, since it might be used to crack the encryption codes  securing all our e-commerce.  However, more than 10 years have sped by as group after group have claimed imminent success, only to have the headlines fade a week or so later.  Unfortunately by now, most people in the physics and computer world have come to accept the idea that quantum computers are just around the corner or already working in a secret lab somewhere.

 

Well, I'm relieved to report that our 45 year detour in the quantum desert is just about over.  A paper by an Oxford physicist with the unlikely name of Joy Christian has, according to him, identified a fatal flaw in Bell's formula.  This flaw discredits the significance of the Bell-inspired experiments for validating the reality of entanglement.

 

I will review the basics of quantum mechanics, the notion of entanglement, its egregious misuse by the paranormal groupies (such as the cringeworthy film What the Bleep), and other implications of Bell's formula.  I will explain as best I can the new discovery by Dr. Christian, and show why the emperor has no clothes.

 

Please see my short online essay on this subject titled "The Entanglement Illusion"

 

http://cyberneticmoments.com/entanglement_illusion.html

Sunday, 10/24/10

Contact:

Larry Hicok, East Bay Atheists

Website: Click to Visit

Cost:

free

Save this Event:

iCalendar
Google Calendar
Yahoo! Calendar
Windows Live Calendar

Berkeley Public Library

2090 Kittredge
Berkeley, CA 94704
USA